The best colored pencils balance smooth laydown, useful color selection, and cores that suit the way you draw or color. I’d start with Prismacolor Premier Soft Core, 48 Count for a focused artist set, consider the Castle Arts 72 Soft Core for a broader everyday palette, and choose a KALOUR set when a large color range or specialty finish matters most. The main tradeoff is between a manageable set of well-chosen colors and a much larger collection that takes more space and sorting. Core softness, duplicate shades, and case organization can matter more than the headline pencil count. Read on for how the 15 options compare and which set fits your priorities.
Turn the school run and nap time into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Prismacolor Premier 48 Count is the clearest artist-focused choice in this lineup; its smaller palette is easier to manage than the 520- and 550-pencil KALOUR collections.
- Castle Arts 72 Soft Core and the 72 Muted set serve different palette needs: one suits broad everyday coloring, while the other centers subdued tones.
- Large KALOUR assortments offer breadth, but pencil count alone does not tell you how many distinct, useful shades you will reach for.
- KALOUR metallic and neon sets add effects that standard colored pencils cannot provide, but their specialized colors make them poor substitutes for a balanced core set.
- Prismacolor 24 Count is a more contained entry into a soft-core artist pencil, while the 48-count set provides more room for color variation.
| Castle Arts 72 Muted Colored Pencils |  | Best for Muted Palettes | Count: 72 colored pencils | Core type: Wax | Palette: Muted and moody shades | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KALOUR Pro Colored Pencils, 520-Color Set |  | Best for Maximum Color Range | Quantity: 520 colored pencils | Core: Soft and pigment-rich | Color: Multicolor | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Prismacolor Premier Soft Core Colored Pencils, 24 Count |  | Best Compact Artist Set | Count: 24 pencils | Core: Soft and thick | Colors: 24 assorted colors | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KALOUR 180-Color Colored Pencil Set with Tin Case |  | Best Organized Mid-Size Set | Count: 180 pencils | Core: Soft and described as break-resistant | Material: Basswood barrels | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Finenolo 36-Pack Colored Pencils |  | Best Simple Starter Set | Quantity: 36 pencils | Core: Soft | Material: Wood | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KALOUR 72-Piece Metallic Colored Pencils |  | Best for Metallic Effects | Pencil count: 72 | Core: Soft, highly pigmented | Pencil body: Basswood | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Prismacolor Premier Soft Core Colored Pencils, Assorted Colors, 48 Count |  | Best for Blending | Count: 48 pencils | Core: Soft, thick | Colors: Assorted | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils for Adults, Soft Core |  | Best Organized 72-Color Set | Count: 72 colored pencils | Core: Soft, durable | Storage: Three-layer presentation tin | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KALOUR Colored Pencils, 240 Count, 12 Colors |  | Best for Group Coloring | Count: 240 colored pencils | Colors: 12 assorted colors | Included components: 12 sharpeners | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KALOUR 550 Colored Pencil Set with Zipper Case |  | Best for Maximum Color Range | Colored pencils: 520 unique colors specified in the description; title says 550 pencils | Metallic colors: 60 | Neon fluorescent colors: 24 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KALOUR 72-Count Soft-Core Colored Pencils |  | Best for Blending on a Budget | Count: 72 pencils | Core: Soft, highly pigmented, break-resistant | Pencil body: Basswood | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Castle Art Supplies 72 Autumn Colored Pencils |  | Best for Autumn Palettes | Brand: Castle Art Supplies | Count: 72 pencils | Core: Wax-based; soft and highly pigmented | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KALOUR 50 Neon Fluorescent Colored Pencils, Soft Core |  | Best for Neon Accents | Brand: KALOUR | Count: 50 pencils | Type: Fluorescent colored pencils | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Soucolor 72-Color Colored Pencil Set |  | Best for Ready-to-Color Convenience | Quantity: 72 pencils | Color: Multicolor | Core: Soft, break-resistant | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KALOUR PDAS 192 Colored Pencils Set with Watercolor Pencils and Accessories |  | Best All-in-One Variety Set | Brand: KALOUR PDAS | Pencil count: 192 | Pencil types: 159 standard, 15 metallic, 6 fluorescent, 12 watercolor | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| colored pencil | Core | Count |
|---|---|---|
| Castle Arts 72 Muted Colored P | — | 72 colored pencils |
| KALOUR Pro Colored Pencils | Soft and pigment-rich | — |
| Prismacolor Premier Soft Core | Soft and thick | 24 pencils |
| KALOUR 180-Color Colored Penci | Soft and described as break-resistant | 180 pencils |
| Finenolo 36-Pack Colored Penci | Soft | — |
| KALOUR 72-Piece Metallic Color | Soft, highly pigmented | — |
| Prismacolor Premier Soft Core | Soft, thick | 48 pencils |
| Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored | Soft, durable | 72 colored pencils |
| KALOUR Colored Pencils | Soft, highly pigmented, described as break-resistant | 240 colored pencils |
| KALOUR 550 Colored Pencil Set | — | — |
| KALOUR 72-Count Soft-Core Colo | Soft, highly pigmented, break-resistant | 72 pencils |
| Castle Art Supplies 72 Autumn | Wax-based; soft and highly pigmented | 72 pencils |
| KALOUR 50 Neon Fluorescent Col | Soft | 50 pencils |
| Soucolor 72-Color Colored Penc | Soft, break-resistant | — |
| KALOUR PDAS 192 Colored Pencil | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Castle Arts 72 Muted Colored Pencils
Castle Arts 72 Muted Colored Pencils earns a place for artists who want a coordinated, subdued range instead of a box dominated by brights. Its 72 wax-core shades are described as smooth for blending and detailed work, giving colored-pencil drawings room for gentle transitions and moody color choices. Compared with Prismacolor Premier Soft Core Colored Pencils, 24 Count, this set offers three times as many pencils and a more restrained palette, while Prismacolor is the clearer fit for vivid, saturated color in a compact selection. Tutorials and coloring projects make this Castle Arts set more approachable for guided practice. The tradeoff is that its adult-artist focus and limited product details leave less guidance for younger users and little information about individual colors or lightfastness.
Pros:- 72 complementary muted shades suit subdued artwork
- Smooth wax cores are designed for blending
- Cores are described as resistant to snapping and easy to sharpen
- Includes step-by-step tutorials and coloring projects
Cons:- Adult-artist focus may not suit younger beginners
- Individual color and lightfastness details are not provided
Best for: Adult colorists and illustrators who prefer subdued palettes and want guided projects alongside a broad set of blending pencils.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking vivid, individually documented shades or lightfastness information, since those details are not provided.
- Count:72 colored pencils
- Core type:Wax
- Palette:Muted and moody shades
- Intended work:Blending and detailed work
- Included:Step-by-step tutorials and coloring projects
- Packaging:Gift-ready tin
Our verdict“Choose this set for a broad, guided muted palette; choose Prismacolor Premier 24 Count for a smaller selection aimed at vivid color.”
KALOUR Pro Colored Pencils, 520-Color Set
KALOUR Pro Colored Pencils, 520-Color Set is the range-first choice here: its 520 distinct colors give artists more options for subtle shifts and specific hues than the 180-pencil KALOUR set. Soft, pigment-rich cores are described as suited to blending, layering, sketching, and detailed coloring, while individual color codes and names make a sprawling collection easier to navigate. The listed lightfastness ratings add a reference point when choosing colors for artwork. A metal case supports storage and portability, though a set this large still calls for substantial space and deliberate organization. Compared with Prismacolor Premier Soft Core Colored Pencils, 24 Count, this is better for breadth than a compact, focused selection. The available product details do not establish how the pencils perform in practice, so buyers seeking independently described handling may prefer a smaller set with more specific performance information.
Pros:- 520 distinct colors offer exceptional palette breadth
- Soft, pigment-rich cores are described as suitable for blending and layering
- Individual color codes and names help identify shades
- Metal case provides a dedicated storage option
Cons:- Large collection needs considerable storage and organization
- Product information provides limited evidence about real-world performance
Best for: Experienced colorists and illustrators who want a very large labeled palette for detailed projects and frequent color selection.
Not ideal for: Travelers with limited storage or beginners who would find hundreds of choices difficult to organize and use.
- Quantity:520 colored pencils
- Core:Soft and pigment-rich
- Color:Multicolor
- Case:Metal
- Safety:Described as non-toxic
- Color identification:Individual color code and name
- Lightfastness information:Rating listed for each pencil
- Intended uses:Blending, layering, sketching, and detailed coloring
Our verdict“Pick this for maximum labeled color choice, while the 180-pencil KALOUR set is a more manageable broad-palette option.”
Prismacolor Premier Soft Core Colored Pencils, 24 Count
Prismacolor Premier Soft Core Colored Pencils, 24 Count favors a focused artist set over sheer quantity. Its soft, thick cores and richly saturated pigments are described as suited to smooth shading, blending, and layering, so a modest color selection can still support tonal work. Compared with KALOUR Pro Colored Pencils, 520-Color Set, it is far easier to carry and sort, though it offers a fraction of the color range. The tin keeps the 24 pencils together, making this a practical option for artists building a portable kit or trying soft-core pencils before committing to a large collection. The pencils arrive unsharpened, so they are not ready for fine detail straight out of the tin. They are also listed as not water resistant, which rules them out for techniques that rely on water exposure.
Pros:- Soft, thick cores support blending, shading, and layering
- Richly saturated pigments suit vivid artwork
- Portable tin keeps the compact set together
- Leads are described as resistant to cracking and chipping
Cons:- Only 24 colors compared with large KALOUR sets
- Pencils arrive unsharpened
- Not water resistant
Best for: Artists who want a portable, small-format set of soft-core pencils for saturated shading, blending, and layering.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a broad palette, pre-sharpened pencils, or water-resistant color for their work.
- Count:24 pencils
- Core:Soft and thick
- Colors:24 assorted colors
- Material:Wood
- Case:Tin
- Pencil condition:Unsharpened
- Lead:Described as resistant to cracking and chipping
- Water resistance:Not water resistant
Our verdict“Choose this compact Prismacolor set for saturated soft-core work on the go; choose the 520-color KALOUR set when range matters more than portability.”
KALOUR 180-Color Colored Pencil Set with Tin Case
KALOUR 180-Color Colored Pencil Set with Tin Case balances substantial color choice with a storage system that helps keep the pencils identifiable. Every pencil is numbered and named, and the tin’s built-in tray separates the collection—a useful step up in organization from sets with a basic case. Its 180 soft, richly pigmented cores are described as suitable for blending and layering, giving it a wider working palette than Castle Arts 72 Muted Colored Pencils. That extra range makes color matching more flexible, but the larger case is bulkier to carry and the product information does not mention an included sharpener. Basswood barrels are described as easy to sharpen, while the stated safety standards may matter to buyers choosing supplies for shared spaces. This set suits artists who want many shades without jumping to KALOUR’s 520-pencil collection.
Pros:- 180 colors offer broader choice than 72-pencil sets
- Numbered and named pencils simplify color identification
- Built-in tray helps keep the tin organized
- Soft, richly pigmented cores are described as suitable for blending and layering
Cons:- Tin and full set may be bulky to carry
- No sharpener is mentioned in the product information
Best for: Home and classroom colorists who want a broad, labeled palette organized in a divided tin.
Not ideal for: Artists who prioritize a light travel kit or need a sharpener included in the set.
- Count:180 pencils
- Core:Soft and described as break-resistant
- Material:Basswood barrels
- Color identification:Numbered and named
- Case:Tin box with built-in plastic tray
- Safety:Described as non-toxic; conforms to ASTM D-4236 and EN71-3
- Line size:3 millimeters
- Shape:Round
Our verdict“Choose this for an organized, broad palette at a more manageable scale than KALOUR’s 520-pencil set.”
Finenolo 36-Pack Colored Pencils
Finenolo 36-Pack Colored Pencils is a straightforward entry point for buyers who want a moderate set for coloring, drawing, and sketching without managing a large collection. Its soft cores are described for several creative uses, and ribbed, round wooden bodies give the pencils a distinct grip detail. Compared with Prismacolor Premier Soft Core Colored Pencils, 24 Count, Finenolo includes 12 more pencils, but the supplied information does not describe pigment saturation, lead durability, or blending performance with the same specificity. That makes it harder to judge for demanding artist work. Its suitability for ages 12 and up gives families a clear age marker, while the ambidextrous design fits left- and right-handed users. The product details do not clarify whether a sharpener is included, so buyers should plan for that separately if they need one.
Pros:- 36 multicolor pencils cover basic coloring and drawing needs
- Soft cores are described for coloring, drawing, sketching, and painting
- Ribbed grip provides a textured barrel
- Ambidextrous design suits left- and right-handed users
Cons:- Product details provide little evidence about pigment or lead performance
- Sharpener inclusion is unclear
Best for: Families with artists aged 12 and up who need a basic multicolor set for casual coloring, drawing, and sketching.
Not ideal for: Artists who need documented blending performance, a large palette, or clear information about included sharpening tools.
- Quantity:36 pencils
- Core:Soft
- Material:Wood
- Shape:Round
- Colors:Multicolor
- Grip:Ribbed
- Hand orientation:Ambidextrous
- Recommended age:12 and up
Our verdict“Choose Finenolo for a simple 36-pencil set for casual use, while Prismacolor 24 Count offers more specific artist-focused performance details.”
KALOUR 72-Piece Metallic Colored Pencils
Metallic shimmer gives this set a clear role: it adds reflective accents that ordinary colored pencils, including Prismacolor Premier Soft Core, are not designed to provide. The 72 pencils also have soft, highly pigmented cores for layering and blending, while the colorless blender and sketch pencil support basic drawing workflows. Its gift tin and coloring chart make the set easier to store and organize than loose pencils. The tradeoff is that shimmer is most visible on dark paper, so artists working mainly on white pages may see less difference from a standard set. Buyers seeking nuanced conventional shades should compare it with Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils, which is aimed at a broader everyday palette.
Pros:- Metallic finish adds reflective accents, especially on dark paper
- Soft, highly pigmented cores support layering and blending
- Includes a colorless blender and sketch pencil
- Gift tin and DIY coloring chart help with storage and organization
Cons:- Metallic shimmer may be subtle on light paper
- The metallic focus may leave less room for conventional shades than an everyday art set
Best for: Colorists and illustrators who want metallic highlights that show clearly on dark paper, plus a broad set for blending and layering
Not ideal for: Artists who mainly work on white paper or need a conventional, carefully differentiated palette without metallic emphasis
- Pencil count:72
- Core:Soft, highly pigmented
- Pencil body:Basswood
- Included accessories:Colorless blender pencil, sketch pencil, DIY coloring chart
- Storage:Gift tin
- Item weight:0.76 kg
Our verdict“Choose this set for metallic highlights and dark-paper work; choose Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils for a more conventional coloring palette.”
Prismacolor Premier Soft Core Colored Pencils, Assorted Colors, 48 Count
Soft, thick cores and richly saturated pigments make this 48-pencil set a strong fit for artists who build color through shading, blending, and layers. Compared with KALOUR 72-Piece Metallic Colored Pencils, Prismacolor puts its emphasis on smooth conventional color rather than shimmer effects. The smaller count also keeps the selection more manageable than Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils, though it offers fewer color choices for broad palettes. Color-coded casings and a portable tin make it easier to identify and carry the pencils. The leads are described as waterproof and resistant to breaking and chipping, but soft cores can still require care during sharpening, and the tin’s artwork may vary. Pick it for expressive blending; skip it if breadth matters more than core feel.
Pros:- Soft, thick cores support smooth blending, shading, and layering
- Richly saturated pigments create vivid coverage
- Leads are described as waterproof and resistant to breaking and chipping
- Color-coded casings and portable tin aid identification and storage
Cons:- Forty-eight colors offer less palette breadth than the 72-pencil Castle Art set
- Soft cores may need more careful sharpening for fine details
- Tin case artwork may vary
Best for: Colored-pencil artists who prioritize saturated, blendable cores for shading and layered illustrations
Not ideal for: Beginners seeking the widest color selection in one set or artists who prefer firmer cores for fine detail
- Count:48 pencils
- Core:Soft, thick
- Colors:Assorted
- Case:Portable tin
- Lead features:Blendable, waterproof, slow-wearing; described as resistant to breaking and chipping
- Package dimensions:9-3/4 × 8-1/8 × 7/8 inches
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“Choose Prismacolor Premier when smooth blending and saturated color matter more than having the broadest palette.”
Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils for Adults, Soft Core
Named, numbered, color-coded pencils make this set easier to sort and return to than an assortment identified only by shade, while its three-layer tin keeps the full 72-color range organized. The soft cores suit smooth coverage, layering, blending, and burnishing, giving it a broader everyday role than the metallic-focused KALOUR 72-piece set. A fold-out tutorial also offers a useful starting point for adults building colored-pencil skills. Its core is described as durable and resistant to crumbling, but the supplied details do not specify accessories for sharpening or blending. The broad surface list includes paper, eggshell, canvas, and wood, though buyers should still match paper and technique to their intended work. Compared with Prismacolor Premier’s 48-count set, Castle offers more shades and structured storage, while Prismacolor is the more focused pick for soft-core blending.
Pros:- Seventy-two colors provide a broad palette for varied subjects
- Named, numbered, and color-coded pencils simplify identification
- Soft cores support smooth coverage, layering, blending, and burnishing
- Three-layer tin and fold-out tutorial add organization and guidance
Cons:- Three-layer storage tin takes more space than a compact pencil case
- No blender, sketch pencil, or sharpener is listed among the included items
Best for: Adult colorists who want a broad palette with clear color identification, organized storage, and a basic technique tutorial
Not ideal for: Artists who want metallic effects, included blending tools, or a compact set with fewer colors to manage
- Count:72 colored pencils
- Core:Soft, durable
- Storage:Three-layer presentation tin
- Identification:Named, numbered, and color-coded
- Surfaces:Paper, eggshell, canvas, wood, and more
- Included:Fold-out colored-pencil tutorial
Our verdict“Choose Castle Art for an organized 72-color everyday set with a tutorial, especially if metallic effects are not a priority.”
KALOUR Colored Pencils, 240 Count, 12 Colors
This set’s 240 pre-sharpened pencils are distributed across just 12 colors, making quantity its main advantage: classrooms, clubs, or families can share colors without passing around a small handful of each. Twelve included sharpeners and clear color-and-number labels make setup straightforward. That differs sharply from Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils, which gives one artist a wider range of distinct hues rather than multiples for a group. The soft, highly pigmented cores are described as break-resistant and suitable for blending and layering, but repeated copies of 12 colors limit nuanced shading and palette variety. It is also a large package at 16.3 × 10.6 × 1.7 inches. Choose it when availability per color matters; for solo artwork with more choices, the Castle set is the better fit.
Pros:- Large supply of 240 pencils supports sharing and frequent use
- Twelve sharpeners are included
- Pre-sharpened pencils reduce setup time
- Color and number labels help identify the 12 shades
Cons:- Only 12 colors limit palette variety and subtle color transitions
- Large package takes substantial storage space
- Individual pencil dimensions are not specified
Best for: Teachers, activity leaders, and families who need many pre-sharpened pencils to share across group coloring sessions
Not ideal for: Individual artists who need many distinct hues for nuanced shading, detailed illustrations, or varied palettes
- Count:240 colored pencils
- Colors:12 assorted colors
- Included components:12 sharpeners
- Material:Basswood
- Core:Soft, highly pigmented, described as break-resistant
- Preparation and identification:Pre-sharpened; labeled by color and number
- Safety standard:ASTM D-4236 and EN71-3
- Recommended age:3 years and up
- Dimensions:16.3 × 10.6 × 1.7 inches
Our verdict“Choose this KALOUR set for group use and plentiful duplicates; choose Castle Art’s 72-color set for greater variety in solo work.”
KALOUR 550 Colored Pencil Set with Zipper Case
With 520 unique colored pencils, including metallic and neon shades, this set offers the broadest stated palette in this batch. Its soft wax-based cores are intended for smooth coloring and blending, and the kit adds sketch and blender pencils, erasers, sharpeners, a swatch card, and a seven-compartment zippered case. That makes it more self-contained than the 72-pencil Castle Art set, while the Castle tin is easier to manage for someone who wants a smaller everyday palette. The main tradeoff is scale: this is a bulky kit, even with a handle and shoulder strap. There is also a product-detail mismatch: the title says 550 pencils, but the description specifies 520 colored pencils. I would choose it for range and accessories, after confirming the delivered set’s contents.
Pros:- Description specifies 520 unique colors, including metallic and neon shades
- Soft wax-based cores are intended for smooth application and blending
- Includes blender and sketch pencils, erasers, sharpeners, and a swatch card
- Seven zippered compartments and two carrying options help organize the set
Cons:- Large case may be bulky to carry and store
- Title says 550 pencils while the description specifies 520 colored pencils
- A very large palette may take time to sort and manage
Best for: Artists who want a very wide selection, including metallic and neon shades, with drawing tools and organized portable storage
Not ideal for: Travelers who need a compact pencil kit or buyers who want an unambiguous item count without checking the listing details
- Colored pencils:520 unique colors specified in the description; title says 550 pencils
- Metallic colors:60
- Neon fluorescent colors:24
- Core type:Soft wax-based
- Case:Large-capacity bag with 7 zipper compartments
- Carrying options:Built-in handle and detachable shoulder strap
- Included accessories:12 rainbow pencils, 3 colorless blender pencils, 3 sketch pencils, 2 eraser pencils, 4 erasers, 6 sharpeners, and a color swatch card
- Materials:Described as non-toxic and eco-friendly
Our verdict“Choose this set for maximum stated color range and bundled tools if you have room for a large case and are comfortable confirming the item count.”
KALOUR 72-Count Soft-Core Colored Pencils
For artists who want room to blend and layer without committing to a specialist palette, KALOUR’s 72 soft-core pencils offer a versatile spread of named, numbered colors. Their soft, highly pigmented cores suit shading and building up color, while the basswood barrels are described as easy to sharpen. Compared with the autumn-specific Castle Art Supplies 72 Autumn Colored Pencils, this set is the more flexible choice for subjects that call for varied hues; Castle Art’s tin and included tutorial make it the more guided package. KALOUR’s tradeoff is that no case or organizer is listed, so keeping the pencils sorted may take extra effort. It also lacks the specialized effects of the neon KALOUR set and the mixed pencil types in the 192-count KALOUR PDAS kit.
Pros:- 72 colors provide flexibility across varied subjects
- Soft, pigmented cores are suited to blending and layering
- Named and numbered pencils make color selection easier
- Basswood bodies are described as easy to sharpen
Cons:- No storage case or organizer is specified
- Does not include the tutorial and practice materials found with Castle Art’s autumn set
Best for: Colorists and hobby artists who want a broad, labeled palette for blending and everyday drawing.
Not ideal for: Artists who need an included organizer, a focused autumn palette, or specialty effects such as metallic and watercolor pencils.
- Count:72 pencils
- Core:Soft, highly pigmented, break-resistant
- Pencil body:Basswood
- Color identification:Numbered and named
- Safety standards:ASTM D-4236 and EN71-3
- Recommended age:5 years and up
Our verdict“Choose this set for a broad, blendable everyday palette if you can supply your own storage.”
Castle Art Supplies 72 Autumn Colored Pencils
Castle Art Supplies’ autumn-focused set makes a stronger case for seasonal illustration than a general-purpose assortment: its 72 wax-based colors are chosen around autumn tones, and the soft cores are described as suitable for blending, layering, and burnishing. A display tin, color testing chart, six coloring sheets, and step-by-step tutorial give colorists a place to start and a way to keep the set organized. Compared with the general KALOUR 72-Count Soft-Core Colored Pencils, this set offers more learning and storage support, but its palette is less adaptable when a project needs a wider spread of unrelated hues. That specialization is the main tradeoff: the autumn range may leave gaps for portraits, bright florals, or subjects that depend on cool or vivid colors.
Pros:- 72 coordinated autumn-inspired colors support seasonal work
- Soft, pigmented wax cores are described as blendable and suitable for burnishing
- Display tin helps keep pencils together
- Color chart, coloring sheets, and tutorial offer structured practice
Cons:- Autumn-focused hues can limit use across varied subjects
- The supplied materials and palette are less suited to artists who already have a preferred color system
Best for: Adult colorists and illustrators who mainly work with fall landscapes, foliage, and warm seasonal scenes.
Not ideal for: Artists seeking an all-purpose palette for varied subjects or a broad selection of bright, cool, and neutral colors.
- Brand:Castle Art Supplies
- Count:72 pencils
- Core:Wax-based; soft and highly pigmented
- Color palette:Autumn-inspired
- Core properties:Blendable and break-resistant
- Included accessories:Display tin, color testing chart, six coloring sheets, step-by-step tutorial
- Recommended use:Coloring
- Age range:Adult
- Model number:5060578200672
Our verdict“Pick this set for organized practice and warm seasonal artwork, provided its narrow palette suits your projects.”
KALOUR 50 Neon Fluorescent Colored Pencils, Soft Core
When a standard assortment needs a jolt of fluorescent color, KALOUR’s 50-pencil neon set serves a more specific purpose than the general-purpose KALOUR 72-Count Soft-Core Colored Pencils. The soft cores are described as smooth and layerable with other colored pencils, and the set is listed for use on white, black, and colored paper. That gives illustrators and sign-style colorists more ways to make accents stand out. The tradeoff is the same feature that defines the set: fluorescent hues are a poor fit for subdued or naturalistic palettes. Although the colors are described as fade-resistant, no specific lightfastness rating is supplied, so buyers creating work for long-term display have less information about color retention than they may want. This is best used as a specialty complement rather than a sole pencil set.
Pros:- Fluorescent hues add high-visibility accents
- Soft cores are described as smooth for coloring
- Can be layered with other colored pencils
- Listed for use on white, black, and colored paper
Cons:- Neon-focused colors are limiting for subdued and naturalistic work
- No specific lightfastness rating is provided
Best for: Illustrators and mixed-media colorists who want vivid fluorescent accents for work on light or dark paper.
Not ideal for: Artists building a single all-purpose set for naturalistic subjects or archival artwork that requires a stated lightfastness rating.
- Brand:KALOUR
- Count:50 pencils
- Type:Fluorescent colored pencils
- Core:Soft
- Line size:2 mm and above
- Features:Blendable, non-toxic, pre-sharpened
- Paper compatibility:White, black, and colored paper
- Body:Round; 8 mm diameter
- Dimensions:9.17 × 7.48 × 1.06 inches
Our verdict“Add this set for fluorescent effects and accents, rather than relying on it as your only palette.”
Soucolor 72-Color Colored Pencil Set
Soucolor’s 72 pre-sharpened pencils are a practical choice for colorists who want to start drawing without preparing each pencil first. Named and numbered colors make it easier to find a shade again, while the soft, break-resistant cores are described as suited to blending and shading. Compared with the KALOUR 72-Count Soft-Core Colored Pencils, Soucolor arrives pre-sharpened and specifies a 3 mm lead, but its listing says the pencils are not water resistant. The provided details also do not mention a storage case, so organization is left to the buyer. This set covers familiar drawing, sketching, and coloring needs, but it does not offer Castle Art’s included practice materials or the specialty fluorescent range of the other KALOUR set. Its strengths are straightforward readiness and a broad everyday palette.
Pros:- 72 colors cover a broad range of drawing and coloring needs
- Pre-sharpened pencils are ready to use
- Named and numbered colors support repeatable shade selection
- Soft, break-resistant cores are described as useful for shading and blending
Cons:- Pencils are not water resistant
- No storage case details are provided
Best for: Beginners, students, and casual colorists who want a labeled set ready for immediate drawing and coloring.
Not ideal for: Artists who need water-resistant marks, included storage, or materials for structured practice.
- Quantity:72 pencils
- Color:Multicolor
- Core:Soft, break-resistant
- Lead size:3 mm
- Material:Wood
- Finish:Pre-sharpened
- Water resistance:Not water resistant
- Safety:Non-toxic; EN71-3 safety certificate
Our verdict“Choose Soucolor for an immediately usable everyday set if water resistance and included storage are not priorities.”
KALOUR PDAS 192 Colored Pencils Set with Watercolor Pencils and Accessories
For artists who want several pencil effects in one portable kit, KALOUR PDAS combines 192 pencils: standard, metallic, fluorescent, and watercolor types. The mix can support varied experiments without assembling separate specialty sets, and the zippered case, sharpeners, blender, burnisher, brush pen, and color chart give the kit practical drawing tools alongside a tutorial. Compared with KALOUR’s 72-count soft-core set, this is far more varied and ready to carry, though the larger assortment may be more than a focused colorist needs. Its standard pencils also share space with specialty types, so a buyer seeking one carefully curated traditional palette may prefer a simpler set such as Castle Art’s autumn selection. The supplied description calls the pencils blendable, lightfast, and break-resistant, but gives no individual breakdown of performance across each pencil type.
Pros:- Includes four pencil types for varied drawing effects
- Portable zippered case has a handle and front pocket
- Drawing and blending tools accompany the pencils
- Tutorial and color chart support guided use and color selection
Cons:- The large mixed set may be excessive for artists who only need standard colored pencils
- Performance details are not broken down by pencil type
Best for: Adult hobby artists who want a portable starter collection covering standard, metallic, fluorescent, and watercolor pencil techniques.
Not ideal for: Traditional colored-pencil artists who want a focused palette or detailed performance specifications for each pencil type.
- Brand:KALOUR PDAS
- Pencil count:192
- Pencil types:159 standard, 15 metallic, 6 fluorescent, 12 watercolor
- Included accessories:2 sharpeners, burnisher, blender, brush pen, white gel pen, pencil extender, marker, tutorial, color chart
- Case:Portable zippered case with handle and front pocket
- Case material:Polyester Oxford fabric
- Pencil features:Described as vibrant, blendable, lightfast, and break-resistant
- Age range:Adult
- Model number:PDAS
Our verdict“Choose this kit for a portable introduction to several pencil techniques, while accepting less detail about each type’s performance.”
How We Picked
I compared these sets around the choices that shape everyday use: core feel, range and usefulness of colors, case organization, and versatility. A larger assortment can help with subtle shading, but it earns its place only when the extra colors add practical choices rather than complexity. I also treated muted, autumn, metallic, neon, and watercolor assortments as distinct tools because each serves a different palette or technique.
The ranking favors sets that appear to offer a useful balance for their intended buyer. The Prismacolor Premier 48 Count leads for a focused artist set, while the Castle Arts 72 Soft Core is a strong general-purpose alternative. Specialty sets and unusually large assortments rank lower for most buyers because their narrow purpose, storage demands, or potential redundancy make them less straightforward first choices. These are product comparisons based on listed product characteristics; I do not claim hands-on testing.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Colored Pencils
Before choosing a set, decide what kind of marks and color decisions you want the pencils to support. Core feel, palette planning, and storage affect your work more than a large number on the tin or case. These broader checks can help you avoid buying a set that looks generous but does not suit your paper, projects, or routine.
Choose Core Feel for Your Paper and Technique
Soft cores generally lay down color with less pressure and make broad, blended passages easier, while firmer cores tend to hold a sharper point longer for small details. Neither feel is universally better: soft leads can wear down faster and may be more prone to breakage, while firm leads can take more effort to build up rich color. Think about how much of your work involves smooth shading versus fine lines before choosing. Paper matters too, since heavily textured paper can use up a soft point quickly. A common mistake is judging pencils only by how dark one test stroke looks. Try to match the core to your typical pressure, paper texture, and level of detail.
Count Distinct Colors, Not Just Pencils
A large set can include useful neighboring shades for gradual transitions, but repeated or near-identical colors may add little to your working palette. If you are learning, a smaller assortment can make color choices less distracting and help you understand mixing through layering. For portraits, landscapes, or other focused subjects, a planned palette may serve you better than the broadest assortment. Check whether the listed count refers to distinct colors or includes repeated pencils, especially with bulk sets. Avoid assuming that more pencils automatically means more creative range. Consider how many hues you need and whether the set gives you light, midtone, and dark options within them.
Match the Palette to Your Subjects
General-purpose sets suit varied subjects, while muted, autumn, neon, and metallic palettes are designed around particular looks. Specialty colors can be useful for accents or a themed project, but a narrow palette may leave you reaching for another set when you switch subjects. If you are buying your first collection, prioritize a balanced mix of common hues before adding effect pencils. A themed set makes more sense when its colors align with recurring work, such as seasonal illustrations or high-visibility highlights. Consider whether you want the specialty pencils to supplement an existing palette or serve as your only set. That distinction can prevent an eye-catching assortment from becoming a limited daily tool.
Check Storage, Sorting, and Portability
Cases shape how quickly you can find a color and whether pencils stay protected between sessions. A tin can be sturdy and easy to stack, but it may take more space and offer less flexibility than a zippered case. Large collections also require more room and time to sort; an impressive assortment is less useful if the colors are difficult to retrieve. If you work at a desk, storage may matter less than having shades grouped clearly. For drawing away from home, favor a compact set you can carry and close securely. Before buying, look for how the pencils are arranged and whether the case appears suited to your workspace.
Pay More for Capabilities You Will Use
A premium or artist-oriented set can make sense when predictable core behavior, richer layering, or a carefully selected palette will support regular work. For casual coloring, gifts, or experimentation, a broad value set may cover your needs without requiring a specialized collection. Added accessories and mixed-media pencils are useful only if you plan to use those tools; otherwise, they can make the set harder to organize without improving your main colored-pencil work. Compare what the extra features let you do, rather than treating them as automatic upgrades. A common buying mistake is paying for a very large range before knowing which colors you prefer. Start with a set that fits your current projects, then expand toward a specific gap.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I choose Prismacolor Premier 24 or 48 Count?
Choose the 24-count set if you want a compact selection of soft-core pencils for practice, travel, or a limited palette. The 48-count set gives you more room to pick neighboring shades and build smoother color changes without relying as often on layering. A larger palette can also mean more time deciding what to use, so it is not automatically the better fit for a beginner. If you already know you enjoy blending and want more color choices in one set, the 48-count option is the more flexible pick. If you are still learning your preferences, starting smaller can keep the collection manageable.
Are the 520- and 550-pencil KALOUR sets better than a 72-pencil set?
They offer far more listed pencils, which can appeal to artists who want many shades available at once. That count does not by itself establish how many distinct colors are included or how useful each shade will be for your work. Large cases also take more space and can make it slower to find a specific pencil. A 72-pencil set may be easier to store and use as a daily palette, especially for coloring or occasional drawing. Choose a very large assortment when range is a real need and you have a plan for organizing it.
Can a metallic or neon set replace a regular colored-pencil palette?
A metallic or neon collection is best treated as a specialty tool because it focuses on distinctive effects or bright fluorescent hues. Those colors can add accents that a conventional palette does not provide, but they may not cover the balanced range needed for subjects such as landscapes or portraits. If you only want occasional highlights, a specialty set can complement pencils you already own. If it would be your only set, a general-purpose palette is likely to support more kinds of work. Match the purchase to the role you expect the pencils to play.
Is a soft-core set a good choice for someone learning to draw?
Soft-core pencils can feel approachable because they lay down color readily and can make blending easier without heavy pressure. The tradeoff is that the points may wear down faster, and softer leads can be less suited to long stretches of tiny detail. Beginners can learn with either core type, so the best fit depends on whether you want broad shading or precise lines. A modest set with a usable range can be easier to learn than an oversized collection. Check that your paper has enough texture for layering without making the pencils difficult to control.
When does a themed set such as muted or autumn pencils make sense?
A themed palette makes sense when its colors match the subjects or mood you return to often. Muted shades can support subdued illustrations, while an autumn assortment centers a seasonal range; either may reduce time spent selecting colors for that kind of work. The same focus can limit versatility if you regularly draw varied subjects or want vivid primary hues. These sets are often more useful as additions to a balanced collection than as a first and only palette. Before buying, ask whether the theme fills a recurring gap in your current pencils.
Conclusion
For the strongest all-around artist-focused pick, I’d choose the Prismacolor Premier 48 Count: it offers more palette flexibility than the 24-count set while staying far more contained than the huge KALOUR assortments. The Castle Arts 72 Soft Core is my best value-style choice for buyers who want a broader general palette, while the Prismacolor 24 Count makes a sensible first set for beginners who prefer fewer decisions. For a premium-feeling, focused artist set, Prismacolor is the lineup’s clearest fit; buyers wanting the widest assortment can look to KALOUR’s large collections if they are ready to manage the storage. Choose KALOUR metallic or neon pencils for special effects, and the muted or autumn Castle Arts sets when their palettes match your subjects. The right set is the one whose core, colors, and format fit how you actually plan to draw or color.
Evergreen bestsellers Picks
bestsellers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
